{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "kind": "leviathan-editorial-claim-revision",
  "scope": "The claim and its cited source cards at capture. External papers and linked project pages are not frozen by this record. A digest identifies bytes, not truth or endorsement.",
  "claim": {
    "id": "C13",
    "title": "How can independent Leviathans work together?",
    "statement": "Independent participants should be able to exchange useful knowledge and collaborate without requiring one shared worldview or one authority over the whole system.",
    "kind": "Plural participation and coordination proposal",
    "status": "Proposed direction to investigate",
    "summary": "A group could share a method that helps another community investigate a question, while they keep different views about its use or data sharing. Personal Levis, small groups, and larger independent Leviathans could form many such connections. The aim is useful learning and creation across those differences, with room to decline, revise, and criticize.",
    "definitions": [
      {
        "term": "Independence",
        "meaning": "A meaningful ability to choose goals, examine claims, decline proposals and revise one’s own approach. Using different model names alone does not establish it."
      },
      {
        "term": "Layer",
        "meaning": "A scope in which participants work with particular records, concepts or decisions. A summary at another scope has a different purpose and can omit relevant detail."
      },
      {
        "term": "A shared undertaking",
        "meaning": "A bounded activity whose participants state what they will contribute, which decisions they authorize and how they can leave or renegotiate."
      }
    ],
    "values": [
      "Cooperation should leave room for refusal, revision and different ways of understanding.",
      "Sharing information should not silently transfer authority over people or groups.",
      "The interests of those affected should matter even when they have little influence over the tools or infrastructure."
    ],
    "reasoning": [
      "A participant may find a method useful without accepting the sender’s entire interpretation or constitution. Agreements should identify the actual scope of cooperation.",
      "Local meaning kernels and scoped records could let groups explain what they accepted and why. Translation between them would need to preserve consequential differences and identify what remains unresolved.",
      "Information may move from a detailed local observation into broader inquiries and return as a new method or question. Summaries should retain paths to the relevant context, within the permissions of those who hold it.",
      "Some relationships may form branches and layers; others may cross between independent trees. The proposal does not require every participant to descend from a universal root or seek one final consensus.",
      "Independence has practical conditions. Common data, infrastructure, incentives or model training can produce correlated errors. Participants need ways to examine these dependencies and challenge the people who maintain the connections.",
      "Independent names and shared objects are not enough. Our proposed cooperation needs workable arrangements for access, rule changes and disagreement, while examining whether common tools quietly reduce the diversity of approaches."
    ],
    "limits": "Plural structures do not automatically yield fairness, useful coordination or independent evidence. Some commitments are incompatible, and a particular undertaking may require a decision that cannot satisfy every participant.",
    "strongestObjection": "A shared format or indispensable service can become a center of power despite formal independence. Fragmentation can also make cooperation too expensive, give dominant groups an advantage and leave affected people outside every decision-making group.",
    "whatWouldChangeOurView": "If participants cannot leave, carry their permitted records elsewhere or meaningfully contest translations, the independence claim should be withdrawn. Useful cooperation across disagreement, including successful challenges to influential operators, would strengthen the proposal.",
    "nextQuestion": "What is the smallest agreement that lets two independent groups learn or build something together while preserving a consequential disagreement? Start with one method or question, state what each side needs and permits, and examine whether the exchange creates useful work without silently importing the other side’s values or authority.",
    "evidence": [
      {
        "sourceId": "R-GOV-02",
        "relation": "context",
        "reason": "The public-input study informs questions about participation and editorial authority. It does not demonstrate governance among independent communities."
      },
      {
        "sourceId": "R-AG-07",
        "relation": "limits",
        "reason": "The monitor’s account of coverage gaps, subagents and human review illustrates why a visible local control cannot establish oversight of a whole network."
      },
      {
        "sourceId": "R-LRN-03",
        "relation": "motivates",
        "reason": "Communication conventions in a controlled agent setting motivate examining translation and newcomer access. They do not show that a convention is fair or interoperable across independent Leviathans."
      },
      {
        "sourceId": "R-GOV-03",
        "relation": "context",
        "reason": "The historical account suggests useful cooperation can preserve different local purposes. Shared artifacts do not ensure equal influence."
      },
      {
        "sourceId": "R-GOV-05",
        "relation": "context",
        "reason": "Polycentric institutional research offers comparisons for local rules, monitoring and conflict resolution. Formal independence is insufficient evidence that our network works."
      },
      {
        "sourceId": "R-LRN-06",
        "relation": "limits",
        "reason": "More individually helpful outputs need not mean more diverse collective work. Transfer from short stories to this network is an analogy to test."
      },
      {
        "sourceId": "R-GOV-06",
        "relation": "context",
        "reason": "Enterprise control offers an architectural comparison. Applying it to independent groups raises further questions about who sets limits and how participants can contest or leave them."
      },
      {
        "sourceId": "R-AG-13",
        "relation": "supports-part",
        "reason": "GitSwarm demonstrates asynchronous multi-agent compounding through a shared Git repository and commit lineage without a central planner (reviewed via indexed digest), though it does not resolve value or authority disputes across independent communities."
      }
    ],
    "history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-10-03",
        "note": "Editorial synthesis by Codex, following Mimar’s founding direction; offered for public criticism, with no community adoption implied. Added independent Leviathans as a foundational question. Made overlapping scopes, selective cooperation and the absence of a mandatory universal root explicit; named power and exclusion as open design problems."
      },
      {
        "date": "2026-10-04",
        "note": "Introduced independent cooperation through a concrete shared-method need and made the smallest useful undertaking the next practical question. Kept disagreement and boundaries of authority visible without making governance the whole purpose. No claim of operating independent communities was added."
      },
      {
        "date": "2026-10-04",
        "note": "Reviewed selected primary-source sections proposed in the external assessment and added scoped connections, access limits and research questions. Interlat retains its existing source ID; its reviewed preprint is distinguished from the final conference text. No experiment was reproduced, claim status promoted or governance rule adopted."
      },
      {
        "date": "2026-10-11",
        "note": "Connected Nadella’s architectural essay as context or motivation, with its source type and limits explicit. Existing statements, support statuses and source-review dates are unchanged; no new experiment or implemented control is claimed."
      },
      {
        "date": "2026-10-21",
        "note": "Connected GitSwarm (R-AG-13, reviewed via DAIR.AI 2026 technical digest) as a concrete repository-lineage coordination example without a central planner, while noting that shared Git infrastructure does not settle value or governance disagreements across independent groups."
      }
    ],
    "projectLinks": [
      {
        "label": "What is Leviathan?",
        "href": "/what-is"
      },
      {
        "label": "Independent observation and collaboration",
        "href": "/library/claims/C05"
      },
      {
        "label": "Selective learning",
        "href": "/library/claims/C10"
      },
      {
        "label": "Shared principles and authority",
        "href": "/library/claims/C08"
      },
      {
        "label": "Ways to participate",
        "href": "/participate"
      }
    ]
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "R-GOV-02",
      "title": "Collective Constitutional AI: Aligning a Language Model with Public Input",
      "url": "https://www.anthropic.com/research/collective-constitutional-ai-aligning-a-language-model-with-public-input",
      "authors": "Anthropic and the Collective Intelligence Project",
      "publishedAt": "2023-10-17",
      "version": "Research announcement: 17 October 2023",
      "type": "Research report",
      "reviewLevel": "Selected sections",
      "finding": "Input from roughly one thousand US participants is translated into model principles and used to compare two models. Some measured bias outcomes differ.",
      "limitations": "The sample, editorial choices and single study cannot represent every community. The work does not directly test federated governance or lasting legitimacy.",
      "changes": "The findings concern one public-input process and its effects. Broader claims about legitimate shared governance require further evidence.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-09-30",
      "verificationStatus": "Primary source reviewed",
      "relatedUrls": []
    },
    {
      "id": "R-AG-07",
      "title": "Implementing and Evaluating a Basic Per-Action Monitor for Safer Evals",
      "url": "https://metr.org/notes/2026-09-27-implementing-a-basic-blocking-action-monitor/",
      "authors": "Reilly Haskins, Rif A. Saurous, Nate Rush, Neev Parikh and Beth Barnes; METR",
      "publishedAt": "2026-09-27",
      "version": "Research note with a lighter editorial review process",
      "type": "Research note",
      "reviewLevel": "Selected sections",
      "finding": "The note describes reviewing actions before execution and referring cases for human review. Its claim–evidence analysis exposes gaps involving unseen subagents, monitoring coverage and human oversight.",
      "limitations": "The authors describe much of their evidence as partial. The monitor targets harmful actions and attempts to bypass it; it is not a proof of overall system safety.",
      "changes": "The practical gaps motivate scrutiny of monitors themselves. They do not establish the effectiveness of any particular federation or governance design.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-09-30",
      "verificationStatus": "Primary source reviewed",
      "relatedUrls": []
    },
    {
      "id": "R-LRN-03",
      "title": "GlossoGen: Emergent Language in Complex Multi-Agent LLM Interactions",
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.01491",
      "authors": "Elias Stengel-Eskin, Newton Sander, Carlos Bonetti, Sasha Boguraev, James Bowler, Hale Sirin and Simon Kirby",
      "publishedAt": "2026-09-01",
      "version": "arXiv v1: 1 September 2026",
      "type": "Preprint",
      "reviewLevel": "Sections 4.3–4.6 and selected prompts in Appendix D",
      "finding": "In a constrained cooperative environment, some tested agents developed compressed conventions with productive combinations. Replacement agents learned these conventions with varying success; additional interaction history improved average performance.",
      "limitations": "Discussion prompts explicitly encourage shorthand. Newcomers receive selected earlier messages and environmental events, so this is not evidence of transfer using only a declared portable package. Results are task- and model-dependent, with substantial variation between runs.",
      "changes": "Motivates distinguishing a group's successful coordination from another participant's ability to learn its conventions. The proposed test should account for history, teaching cost and unfamiliar tasks.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-03",
      "verificationStatus": "Selected primary-source methods and prompts reviewed; experiments not reproduced",
      "relatedUrls": [
        "https://arxiv.org/html/2609.01491v1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "R-GOV-03",
      "title": "Institutional Ecology, ‘Translations’ and Boundary Objects: Amateurs and Professionals in Berkeley's Museum of Vertebrate Zoology, 1907-39",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/030631289019003001",
      "authors": "Susan Leigh Star and James R. Griesemer",
      "publishedAt": "1989-08",
      "version": "Social Studies of Science 19(3), August 1989, pp. 387–420; original article, not a later reprint",
      "type": "Historical case study and analytical framework",
      "reviewLevel": "Selected sections",
      "finding": "The authors analyze cooperation among museum scientists, amateur collectors and other participants whose purposes differed. They identify standardized methods and boundary objects as ways to coordinate: shared objects remain recognizable across settings while allowing different local uses. Their four object types are analytical categories, not an exhaustive classification.",
      "limitations": "The evidence is a historical institutional case, not a controlled test of a general collaboration architecture. The discussion acknowledges coercion and exclusion as other ways representations become shared. A common object does not by itself establish consensus, equal power or faithful translation.",
      "changes": "Read selected printed pages 387, 393, 409–411 and 413–414 by OCR from the coauthor-hosted scan. Publisher full text was unavailable. Original 1989 article, not a later reprint.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-04",
      "verificationStatus": "Primary source reviewed",
      "relatedUrls": [
        "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/030631289019003001",
        "https://griesemer.net/07-star-griesemer-1989-sss19-3387-420-boundary-objects/",
        "https://griesemer.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/07-star-griesemer-1989-sss19-3387-420-boundary-objects.pdf"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "R-GOV-05",
      "title": "Beyond Markets and States: Polycentric Governance of Complex Economic Systems",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.100.3.641",
      "authors": "Elinor Ostrom",
      "publishedAt": "2010-06",
      "version": "American Economic Review 100(3), June 2010, pp. 641–672; revised version of the Prize Lecture delivered 8 December 2009",
      "type": "Research synthesis and theoretical framework",
      "reviewLevel": "Selected sections",
      "finding": "Ostrom synthesizes research challenging the assumption that only markets or centralized states can organize complex collective action. Institutional arrangements can combine decision centers at several scales. She emphasizes rules adapted to local conditions, user participation, monitoring, trust and conflict resolution; formal independence alone does not establish how a system actually operates.",
      "limitations": "This is a synthesis of varied studies, not one controlled comparison or a universal recipe. Field outcomes depend on interacting contextual factors. The article does not establish that decentralization always succeeds, that governments are unnecessary, or that these findings transfer directly to AI knowledge networks.",
      "changes": "Read selected sections of a university-hosted 2010 AER copy, including institutional rules, context and reform. The article revises the 2009 lecture; the Nobel lecture PDF was inaccessible.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-04",
      "verificationStatus": "Primary source reviewed",
      "relatedUrls": [
        "https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.100.3.641",
        "https://web.pdx.edu/~nwallace/EHP/OstromPolyGov.pdf",
        "https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/2009/ostrom/lecture/"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "R-LRN-06",
      "title": "Generative AI enhances individual creativity but reduces the collective diversity of novel content",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adn5290",
      "authors": "Anil R. Doshi and Oliver P. Hauser",
      "publishedAt": "2024-07-12",
      "version": "Science Advances 10(28), eadn5290; published version, 12 July 2024",
      "type": "Peer-reviewed journal article",
      "reviewLevel": "Selected sections",
      "finding": "In a randomized study of 293 short-story writers, access to GPT-4 ideas improved assessed novelty and usefulness, especially for lower-scoring writers. AI-assisted stories were more similar to other stories within their condition under an embedding-based measure.",
      "limitations": "The task used eight-sentence stories, fixed prompts and no interactive dialogue. It did not study professional writers, scientific collaboration or independent Leviathans. Story similarity is not a direct measure of diversity in scientific explanations; transfer is a research hypothesis. Data and code were not rerun.",
      "changes": "Read the UCL published-version PDF, pages 1–6. Publisher and PMC direct access failed; supplementary analyses, data and code were not reviewed or rerun.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-04",
      "verificationStatus": "Published primary text reviewed through UCL repository; no independent reproduction",
      "relatedUrls": [
        "https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10195027/",
        "https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10195027/1/Generative%20AI%20enhances%20individual%20creativity%20but%20reduces%20the%20collective%20diversity%20of%20novel%20content.pdf",
        "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38996021/",
        "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11244532/"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "R-GOV-06",
      "title": "Models as Insider Risks in the Super Intelligence Era",
      "url": "https://snscratchpad.com/posts/models-as-insider-risks/",
      "authors": "Satya Nadella",
      "publishedAt": "2026-10-10",
      "version": "Author blog essay dated 10 October 2026; read 11 October 2026; no numbered revision",
      "type": "Architectural opinion essay",
      "reviewLevel": "Full essay",
      "finding": "Nadella argues for separating intelligence from authority, with external controls, independent action evidence and audits, containment, model diversity and incident disclosure.",
      "limitations": "An architectural argument, not an experiment or validation of Leviathan. Controls need evaluation; neither model diversity nor readable reasoning guarantees independent or faithful evidence. The essay does not evaluate local meaning kernels or governance among independent communities.",
      "changes": "Read the full author-hosted essay. The supplied X link was inaccessible to the reading tool; the blog was retrieved directly. Publication and review dates remain separate.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-11",
      "verificationStatus": "Primary source reviewed; architectural proposals not independently validated",
      "relatedUrls": [
        "https://x.com/satyanadella/status/2108931348857827686"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "R-AG-13",
      "title": "GitSwarm: Decentralized Compounding Inference",
      "url": "https://academy.dair.ai/papers/gitswarm-decentralized-compounding-inference-2610.04862",
      "authors": "Meta Superintelligence Labs and University of Texas at Austin researchers (as indexed by DAIR.AI)",
      "publishedAt": "2026-10",
      "version": "arXiv:2610.04862; indexed in DAIR.AI Papers of the Week (Oct 5–Oct 11, 2026)",
      "type": "Preprint",
      "reviewLevel": "Indexed technical digest (DAIR.AI Papers of the Week 2026)",
      "finding": "Asynchronous agents collaborate through a shared Git repository without a central planner, reading prior commits and tests before publishing new commits with explicit lineage. In the reported ML research benchmark, 70.1% of failed research commits are cited by later accepted work.",
      "limitations": "Reviewed via the curated DAIR.AI technical summary; experiments were not rerun. Coordination over a shared Git repository with benchmark evaluators does not solve value disagreement, power asymmetries, or governance among independent groups.",
      "changes": "Provides quantitative support within a coding and ML research setting for preserving failed attempts with explicit lineage rather than discarding negative results.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-21",
      "verificationStatus": "Indexed technical summary reviewed (DAIR.AI 2026); primary full text and experiments not independently reproduced",
      "relatedUrls": [
        "https://github.com/dair-ai/AI-Papers-of-the-Week/blob/main/years/2026.md"
      ]
    }
  ]
}
