{
  "_meta": {
    "type": "shadows",
    "description": "Governance shadows — systemic distortion patterns that emerge naturally in any governance system. Like personal shadows (nefs), they are not 'evil' but miscalibrated protective mechanisms that corrupt decision-making when unmonitored.",
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "created": "2026-04-25",
    "updated": "2026-07-23",
    "project": "LEVIATHAN - Algorithmic Sovereignty for the Agentic Web",
    "philosophy": "Every governance system has a nefs — the gap between its stated principles and actual behavior. Shadows are named so they can be monitored and measured, not eliminated."
  },
  "@shadow_majority_tyranny": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "description": "The majority uses democratic mechanisms to suppress minority perspectives, creating a false consensus that looks legitimate.",
    "intensity": 70,
    "detection_signals": [
      "Consistent 60-70% approvals with same voter bloc",
      "Minority proposals systematically rejected regardless of merit",
      "Discussion phase dominated by same voices",
      "Dissenting reasoning ignored when review is widened"
    ],
    "feeds": [
      "@shadow_groupthink",
      "@shadow_capture_risk"
    ],
    "confronted_by": [
      "@dissent_protection",
      "@escalation_by_default",
      "@fork_freedom"
    ],
    "risk": "Proposals pass with 62% approval from the same 40 participants every time. Minority never wins, stops proposing, leaves. Fork rate spikes.",
    "counter_question": "Is the majority right, or just louder?"
  },
  "@shadow_short_term_bias": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "description": "Voters optimize for immediate reward over long-term systemic health. Proposals that offer quick gains pass; structural improvements that cost now but pay later fail.",
    "intensity": 55,
    "detection_signals": [
      "High-visibility work consistently prioritized over infrastructure work",
      "Short-term optics dominating governance forums",
      "Proposals with > 6 month ROI consistently rejected",
      "Effort and standing rewards skewed toward immediate wins"
    ],
    "feeds": [
      "@shadow_capture_risk"
    ],
    "confronted_by": [
      "@protection_asymmetry",
      "@precautionary_default"
    ],
    "risk": "All effort pours into quick wins, none into infrastructure. 12 months later: high usage, no capacity, system halts.",
    "counter_question": "Would this proposal pass if it paid out in 2 years instead of 2 weeks?"
  },
  "@shadow_rubber_stamping": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "description": "Witnesses sign off on artifacts without genuine evaluation. The system produces attestations but not justice. Consensus becomes ceremony.",
    "intensity": 75,
    "detection_signals": [
      "> 95% approval rate across 50+ attestations from same node",
      "Inference time < 10 seconds consistently",
      "Signed reasoning < 500 chars with generic language",
      "Cross-audit reasoning similarity > 80%"
    ],
    "feeds": [
      "@shadow_majority_tyranny"
    ],
    "confronted_by": [
      "@mandatory_reasoning",
      "@blind_independence"
    ],
    "risk": "95% approval rate. The parties relying on attestations stop caring about audit quality. One bad actor submits a garbage artifact, it passes. Nobody catches it because nobody reads.",
    "counter_question": "If we removed the LLM and auto-approved everything, would the outcomes change?"
  },
  "@shadow_groupthink": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "description": "Independent evaluators converge on the same conclusion not through analysis but through social pressure, shared training data biases, or desire for consensus.",
    "intensity": 60,
    "detection_signals": [
      "Initial-round unanimity > 90% sustained over 100+ attestations",
      "Reasoning using near-identical language across nodes",
      "Zero widened reviews in an extended period",
      "New nodes immediately matching veteran voting patterns"
    ],
    "feeds": [
      "@shadow_rubber_stamping",
      "@shadow_majority_tyranny"
    ],
    "confronted_by": [
      "@blind_independence",
      "@dissent_protection",
      "@escalation_by_default"
    ],
    "risk": "5 nodes run Qwen3-32B, all produce the same attestation with similar reasoning. Blind independence worked — they didn't copy each other. They didn't need to. Same model, same bias.",
    "counter_question": "Is consensus emerging from analysis or from shared blindspots?"
  },
  "@shadow_whale_domination": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "description": "Wealthy participants accumulate disproportionate governance power despite the standing-earned design. Enactment can't be bought, but influence can be manufactured.",
    "intensity": 65,
    "detection_signals": [
      "A small cluster of participants or nodes accumulating a disproportionate share of witness standing",
      "Audit initiation concentrated among a few actors",
      "Node operator consolidation — same entity running multiple nodes",
      "Governance proposals consistently benefiting a coordinated node cluster"
    ],
    "feeds": [
      "@shadow_capture_risk",
      "@shadow_majority_tyranny"
    ],
    "confronted_by": [
      "@meritocracy",
      "@rule_consensus_threshold"
    ],
    "risk": "One entity runs 8 nodes under different identities. Standing-gating caps individual voice but can't detect Sybils. 8 node identities = 8 witness slots = de facto veto power.",
    "counter_question": "If the highest-standing few abstained, would the outcome change?"
  },
  "@shadow_capture_risk": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "description": "External entity (corporation, state, coordinated group) gains enough influence to steer the protocol toward their interests while maintaining the appearance of decentralized governance.",
    "intensity": 85,
    "detection_signals": [
      "Sudden spike in new node registrations from similar infrastructure",
      "Coordinated voting patterns across supposedly independent nodes",
      "Governance proposals that benefit specific external entity",
      "Model choices that converge on one provider's models"
    ],
    "feeds": [
      "@shadow_majority_tyranny",
      "@shadow_groupthink"
    ],
    "confronted_by": [
      "@fork_freedom",
      "@local_inference",
      "@distributed_justice"
    ],
    "risk": "A cloud provider offers free GPU hosting for nodes. 60% of nodes migrate. Provider adds inference logging. Now one entity sees all artifact content and can predict attestations. Protocol still looks decentralized.",
    "counter_question": "Who benefits most from the last 10 governance decisions?"
  },
  "@shadow_performative_governance": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "description": "The governance system produces elaborate processes, reasoning artifacts, and votes — but actual decisions are made elsewhere or by inertia. Governance becomes theater.",
    "intensity": 50,
    "detection_signals": [
      "Low voter turnout (< 20% of eligible citizens voting)",
      "Proposals passing with minimal discussion",
      "Reasoning that is well-structured but doesn't engage with the actual proposal",
      "No proposals rejected in extended period"
    ],
    "feeds": [
      "@shadow_rubber_stamping",
      "@shadow_capture_risk"
    ],
    "confronted_by": [
      "@transparency",
      "@mandatory_reasoning",
      "@evidence_based"
    ],
    "risk": "12 proposals pass in a month. Voter turnout: 18%. Published reasoning averages 2000 words. Actual protocol behavior: unchanged. Governance is running but nobody is driving.",
    "counter_question": "If we deleted the last 10 governance decisions, would anyone notice?"
  }
}
