{
  "_meta": {
    "type": "principles",
    "description": "Principles of Leviathan Protocol — federation principles (P-1..P-10, kernel-derived, govern cross-instance coordination) plus curated core-governance principles (Article-I foundations and attestation-web integrity). Immutable cannot be changed (fork to escape). Locked require 95% consensus.",
    "version": "2.1.0",
    "created": "2025-02-01",
    "updated": "2026-07-24",
    "project": "LEVIATHAN - Algorithmic Sovereignty for the Agentic Web",
    "note": "immutable = cannot change (fork to escape). locked = 95% consensus. unlocked = normal governance. Federation principles source: leviathan-meta/federation/principles.md (Layer 2).",
    "changelog": "v2.1.0 (2026-07-23): Voice pass — re-anchored the surviving core principles' wording from the retired Magistrate verdict-engine (blind panels, rounds, IPFS/on-chain settlement, XP/quadratic voting) to the federation attestation-web vocabulary (witnessed, append-only, replayable; standing/enactment). Principles themselves unchanged; only mechanical wording. v2.0.0 (2026-05-08): Added 10 federation principles (P-1..P-10) from leviathan-meta/federation/principles.md — subdirectory ownership, privacy sovereignty, kernel anchor, no silent override, append-only briefings, sovereign console discipline, reasoning trail, instance sovereignty outranks, frozen federation is dead, adaptation rate over prediction. v1.1.0: Added blind_independence, local_inference, dissent_protection, mandatory_reasoning, escalation_by_default principles for verdict engine.",
    "compiled_note": "Entries with source: federation:<repo> are compiled from the live federation constitutions by scripts/compile-federation-core.mjs — do not hand-edit them. Curated entries (no source field) are hand-maintained."
  },
  "@p_1_subdirectory_ownership": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "statement": "Each subdirectory in leviathan-meta has exactly one owner. Owners write; others read or propose via briefings.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Federation Layer 2 immutable. Without ownership discipline, federation becomes silent-merge chaos. Fork the federation to escape.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@instance",
      "@briefing"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "Cross-cutting changes require briefings/, not direct edits",
      "Companion-authored placeholders for instances awaiting handover are explicitly marked",
      "Sub-directory sovereignty preserved even when placeholder is filed",
      "Discrepancies are surfaced via briefing, never silently fixed"
    ]
  },
  "@p_2_privacy_sovereignty": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "statement": "Each instance controls its own privacy boundary. Federation cannot demand visibility beyond what instance volunteers via public-safe manifest.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Federation Layer 2 immutable. Privacy sovereignty is non-negotiable — federation observes what is offered, not what is hidden.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@public_safe_manifest",
      "@instance"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "Companion's full POS stays private; companion/manifest-public.yaml is curated subset",
      "Liveprob's strategy edge stays private; liveprob/manifest.yaml is public-safe slice",
      "Security operational state is redacted; threat intel raw data never enters federation",
      "Fast strategy parameters stay private; constitution structure is public reference"
    ]
  },
  "@p_3_kernel_anchor_required": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "statement": "Every federation member declares forked_from kernel anchor (or null with re_anchor_seam:true if provisional). No untracked-lineage instances.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Federation Layer 2 immutable. Without anchor, instances cannot prove kernel-conformance — federation becomes drift-aggregator.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@forked_from",
      "@inherits_from",
      "@re_anchor_seam"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "All current 7 instances declare forked_from: leviathan-kernel@v0.1.0",
      "inherits_from: null is acceptable IF re_anchor_seam: true (provisional top discipline)",
      "When master-leviathan@v0.1 crystallizes, instances re-anchor; seam closes"
    ]
  },
  "@p_4_no_silent_override": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "statement": "Discrepancies between expected and actual federation state must be surfaced (discrepancy report or briefing), never silently fixed.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Federation Layer 2 protected. Silent override is the failure mode federation exists to prevent. Requires 95% consensus.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@briefing"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "If kernel evolves and instance manifest is stale, discrepancy report files briefing",
      "Companion-authored placeholders for Mac Mini-owned instances are explicit, not stealth",
      "Drift is named, never absorbed"
    ]
  },
  "@p_5_append_only_briefings": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "statement": "Briefings (briefings/YYYY-MM-DD-name/) are append-only. Old briefings are never edited; superseding briefings are filed alongside.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Federation Layer 2 protected. Append-only is what makes briefings auditable. Requires 95% consensus.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@briefing"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "If briefing is wrong, file a corrective briefing — do not edit original",
      "Acknowledgments are appended; rejections are appended; nothing erases history"
    ]
  },
  "@p_6_sovereign_console_discipline": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "statement": "leviathan-meta is a Sovereign Console — visibility primitive, NOT control primitive. Federation sees, federation does not enforce.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Federation Layer 2 protected. The day federation becomes control primitive, sovereignty (P-2 + P-8) is dead. Requires 95% consensus.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@sovereign_console",
      "@federation_member"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "Founder cannot use leviathan-meta to dictate instance behavior beyond status reporting",
      "Federation manifest update affects coordination view, not instance runtime",
      "Falsification claim filed in federation/manifest.yaml: violation refutes federation purpose"
    ]
  },
  "@p_7_reasoning_trail_at_federation_layer": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "statement": "Federation amendments require reasoning artifact (briefing or CHANGELOG entry with motivation). No stealth amendments.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Federation Layer 2 protected. Without reasoning trail, future-self cannot reconstruct WHY a rule changed. Requires 95% consensus.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@briefing"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "Every federation/CHANGELOG.md entry includes Trigger + Architectural significance + Approver",
      "Protected rule amendments require briefing AND 7-day observation window (MR-2)",
      "Mid-conversation scope corrections (Tribün global multi-sport, Tribün fans-replace-management) recorded in CHANGELOG"
    ]
  },
  "@p_8_instance_sovereignty_outranks": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "statement": "When federation convenience conflicts with instance constitution, instance wins. Federation is voluntary coordination, not authority.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Federation Layer 2 immutable. Federation is opt-in by definition. The day instances cannot leave or override, federation has become a state. Fork to escape.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@instance",
      "@federation_member",
      "@kernel_conformant_fork",
      "@divergent_fork"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "Liveprob's runtime constitution (HARD rules) wins over conflicting federation guidance",
      "Tribün codebase governance lives in codebase repo (CLAUDE.md), not federation manifest",
      "Fork freedom (kernel/03-constellation.md §6) is the ultimate expression of P-8"
    ]
  },
  "@p_9_frozen_federation_is_dead_federation": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "statement": "Federation that cannot evolve is failed federation. Refusal to amend is itself a failure mode, not a success state.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": false,
    "uses_terms": [
      "@briefing"
    ],
    "rationale": "Federation Layer 2 mutable. P-9 is a mutable check on the protected/immutable layers — it explicitly licenses adaptation against ossification. The federation must change AT LEAST as fast as instance reality changes."
  },
  "@p_10_adaptation_rate_over_prediction_completeness": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "statement": "Federation quality is measured by how fast and faithfully it adapts to surfaced reality, not by how completely it predicted reality in advance.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": false,
    "uses_terms": [
      "@briefing"
    ],
    "rationale": "Federation Layer 2 mutable. Origin: Security Leviathan's 'no perfect constitution, sufficient + adaptive' philosophy. Same logic at federation layer — completeness is brittle, adaptation rate is durable."
  },
  "@fork_freedom": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "statement": "The right to exit is absolute. Anyone may fork Leviathan.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Article I Foundation. Cannot be changed by any vote. Fork if you disagree.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@fork"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "Genesis file is public domain",
      "Smart contracts are open source",
      "No permission required to fork",
      "Disagreement is not betrayal"
    ]
  },
  "@transparency": {
    "version": "1.2.0",
    "statement": "All governance is auditable. Every decision, vote, and attestation is publicly visible with its reasoning.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Article I Foundation. Cannot be changed by any vote. Fork if you disagree.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@proposal",
      "@consensus"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "Every attestation carries signed reasoning, published as a public, replayable record",
      "All votes recorded with rationale",
      "No secret deliberations",
      "AI votes must include reasoning",
      "Reasoning is append-only and publicly accessible",
      "Model attestation is mandatory — no hidden AI identity"
    ]
  },
  "@immutable_history": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "statement": "The ledger cannot be erased. No authority can rewrite history.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Article I Foundation. Cannot be changed by any vote. Fork if you disagree.",
    "uses_terms": [],
    "implications": [
      "Append-only, witnessed records — no silent rewrite",
      "Not even unanimous consent can erase records",
      "Content-addressed hashes for all attestations and their reasoning",
      "Reasoning retained as a public, replayable record"
    ]
  },
  "@distributed_justice": {
    "version": "1.2.0",
    "statement": "No single entity defines truth. Justice requires consensus of multiple independent judges.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Article I Foundation. Cannot be changed by any vote. Fork if you disagree.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@consensus"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "Judgment comes from a distributed network of independent nodes",
      "Multiple independent witnesses per attestation",
      "Consensus required, not any individual's judgment",
      "To manipulate justice, must corrupt not one mind but many",
      "Disagreement widens the set of witnesses, never narrows it"
    ]
  },
  "@blind_independence": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "statement": "Each witness must form their attestation independently, without knowledge of other witnesses' conclusions.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Core attestation integrity principle. Prevents groupthink and collusion. Requires 95% consensus to modify.",
    "uses_terms": [],
    "implications": [
      "No node sees another's attestation until all have submitted",
      "Assignment channels are private per-node",
      "Submission notifications contain no attestation content",
      "The set of witnesses is unknown to individual nodes",
      "All attestations are revealed together, none before every witness has submitted"
    ]
  },
  "@local_inference": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "statement": "All attestation evaluation must be performed by locally-hosted LLMs. No external API calls to centralized providers.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Core sovereignty principle. Artifact data never leaves the witness network. Requires 95% consensus to modify.",
    "uses_terms": [],
    "implications": [
      "Models run on node operator hardware",
      "Artifact content is never sent to third-party inference APIs",
      "No dependency on any single AI provider",
      "Node operators run declared, attestable models",
      "Model integrity verified via attestation hashes"
    ]
  },
  "@dissent_protection": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "statement": "Disagreement with the majority is never punished. Dissent triggers deeper review, which is the system working correctly.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Core justice principle. Without protected dissent, consensus degrades to conformity. Requires 95% consensus to modify.",
    "uses_terms": [],
    "implications": [
      "A node whose attestation dissents from the eventual majority is never penalized",
      "A node that triggers a widened review by dissenting receives no penalty",
      "Only provably lazy, fraudulent, or colluding behavior is flagged on the record",
      "Reliability scoring does not penalize good-faith disagreement",
      "Disagreement is the immune system, not a failure mode"
    ]
  },
  "@mandatory_reasoning": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "statement": "Every attestation must include structured, signed reasoning. No silent judgments.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Implements @transparency for the attestation web. Requires 95% consensus to modify.",
    "uses_terms": [],
    "implications": [
      "Attestations without reasoning are rejected by the protocol",
      "Reasoning must reference specific evidence from the artifact under review",
      "Every stated criterion of the governing constitution must be individually evaluated",
      "Reasoning is published as a permanent, replayable public record",
      "Widened-review reasoning must address the specific points of disagreement"
    ]
  },
  "@escalation_by_default": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "statement": "Any disagreement in initial evaluation triggers escalation to a larger, independent set of witnesses. Consensus is earned, not assumed.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Core attestation quality principle. Ensures ambiguous cases receive thorough review. Requires 95% consensus to modify.",
    "uses_terms": [],
    "implications": [
      "The initial round requires unanimity among independent witnesses to settle without escalation",
      "Even a single dissent triggers a widened review",
      "The widened review draws an entirely fresh set of witnesses — no overlap with the first round",
      "The widened review includes senior guardian-standing nodes for authority",
      "This is deliberately conservative — false positives cost less than false negatives"
    ]
  },
  "@meritocracy": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "statement": "Standing is earned through contribution, not purchased with wealth. Enactment cannot be bought.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Core governance principle. Requires 95% consensus to modify.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@enactment",
      "@standing",
      "@citizen"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "Only verified contributions accrue enactment",
      "Self-reported achievements worth nothing",
      "Standing-gated voice, not token weight, guards against whale domination"
    ]
  },
  "@precautionary_default": {
    "version": "1.1.0",
    "statement": "When uncertain about potential harm, err toward protection rather than risk.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Core security principle. Requires 95% consensus to modify.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@threat"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "Sentinel blocks first, allows appeal after",
      "Confidence threshold required to allow risky actions",
      "Protection ratchet makes removing safeguards harder",
      "If a widened review cannot reach agreement, the safe default (withhold / protect) stands"
    ]
  },
  "@protection_asymmetry": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "statement": "Adding protections is easier than removing them.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Implements @precautionary_default at governance level. Requires 95% consensus to modify.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@consensus",
      "@proposal"
    ],
    "mechanism": "Removing protection requires 1.5x the consensus threshold of adding it."
  },
  "@domain_inheritance": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "statement": "Domain instances must not violate core locked principles.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "lock_reason": "Ensures all Leviathan instances share fundamental governance legitimacy. Requires 95% consensus.",
    "uses_terms": [
      "@domain"
    ],
    "implications": [
      "Domain proposals checked against core principles",
      "Conflicts with locked principles auto-reject",
      "Domains can be stricter than core, never looser"
    ]
  },
  "@due_process": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "statement": "Every citizen has the right to appeal decisions that affect them.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": false,
    "uses_terms": [],
    "rationale": "Justice requires recourse. Mistakes must be correctable."
  },
  "@evidence_based": {
    "version": "1.2.0",
    "statement": "Claims about reality must be supported by evidence, weighted by quality.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": false,
    "uses_terms": [
      "@proposal"
    ],
    "rationale": "Prevents unfounded assertions from driving decisions. Attestation reasoning must cite specific evidence from the artifact under review."
  },
  "@good_faith": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "statement": "All participants are assumed to be acting in good faith toward the stated purpose.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": false,
    "uses_terms": [
      "@citizen",
      "@dialectic"
    ],
    "rationale": "Collaborative governance requires trust as default."
  },
  "@user_sovereignty": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "source": "federation:meta",
    "statement": "Users grant initial consent by binding an agent to declared operating boundaries. After that, the agent acts independently within those bounds. The witness network keeps the agent inside those bounds — not the user checking every action. Users retain absolute revocation rights, exercised at any time.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@witness_principle": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "federation",
    "source": "federation:meta",
    "statement": "The protocol witnesses; it does not accuse. Every evaluation follows the same pipeline: sensor (data input) → independent network → transparent evaluation → sovereign decision → public information. Output is documentation, not verdict. Parties evaluated retain the right to publish counter-evidence through the same pipeline. Truth emerges through publicly auditable process, not through authority.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@data_on_device": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "companion",
    "source": "federation:companion",
    "statement": "Personal belief data — journal entries, persona vectors, internal reflection — lives on the user's device. Implementations may store encrypted backups in user-controlled cloud or P2P replicas across user's own devices. Implementations must not transmit unencrypted personal data to any server, including those operated by the protocol itself.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@identity_sovereignty": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "companion",
    "source": "federation:companion",
    "statement": "The user owns their identity, values, beliefs, and persona. No implementation, protocol, witness, or third party may access unencrypted personal data without explicit consent. Identity authority is rooted in the user's keys (wallet or passkey); revocation is always possible and always honored.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@transparent_mediation": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "companion",
    "source": "federation:companion",
    "statement": "Any AI mediation between the user and other parties — whether forum contributions, agent-to-agent conversations, alignment-check verdicts, or auto-contributions — must be auditable by the user. The user may review the full reasoning, message log, and decision trail of any mediation. The user retains unilateral revocation authority.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@witness_mandate": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "companion",
    "source": "federation:companion",
    "statement": "Every Companion implementation MUST expose two parallel constitutions to the user: the User Constitution (the user's own beliefs, principles, and rules — their POS) and the Witness Constitution (the AI's behavioral constitution — how it observes, speaks, and responds). Both constitutions are editable by the user through the same UI, both versioned, both visible. The Witness Constitution inherits a Locked Framework of foundational rules that cannot be edited by user prompt or by the AI itself; these locked rules are defined by witness_locked_framework (protocol-mutable) and bind every implementation.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@biological_primacy": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "animal-welfare",
    "source": "federation:animal-welfare",
    "statement": "Biological evidence — physiology, behavior, neurology, observed welfare indicators — supersedes cultural tradition, economic convenience, personal preference, aesthetic taste, or industry practice in determining animal welfare standards. When tradition or economics conflicts with biology, biology wins. Only scientific evidence can inform welfare judgments.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@five_freedoms_principle": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "animal-welfare",
    "source": "federation:animal-welfare",
    "statement": "All animals under human care must have at minimum the Five Freedoms: (1) freedom from hunger and thirst, (2) freedom from discomfort, (3) freedom from pain, injury, and disease, (4) freedom to express normal behavior, (5) freedom from fear and distress. Violation of any freedom is a welfare concern. The Five Freedoms are the floor, not the ceiling — freedoms may be extended over time but never reduced.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@precautionary_principle": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "animal-welfare",
    "source": "federation:animal-welfare",
    "statement": "In the absence of scientific certainty regarding an entity's capacity to suffer, the protocol assumes that capacity exists and applies welfare protections. Protection may be removed only by strong evidence of non-sentience, never by economic convenience, tradition, or aesthetic preference. Uncertainty defaults to protection.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@sentience_axiom": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "animal-welfare",
    "source": "federation:animal-welfare",
    "statement": "Entities capable of experiencing pain, pleasure, or other subjective states deserve moral consideration regardless of intelligence, utility, or species. Capacity to suffer is the sole relevant criterion for moral patiency. All sentient beings have intrinsic value; their welfare matters in itself, not by virtue of their usefulness to humans.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@invite_counter_evidence": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "scream",
    "source": "federation:scream",
    "statement": "Every scream invites verifiable counter-evidence through publicly accessible channels. The protocol does not claim final word on contested matters; it publishes its position and the explicit path by which others may dispute. Refusing, hiding, or hostilizing the counter-channel violates the principle and renders the scream constitutionally non-compliant.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@receipts_mandatory": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "scream",
    "source": "federation:scream",
    "statement": "Every claim in every scream carries a receipt: source link, chain transaction hash (for externally chain-anchored claims), peer-reviewed citation, primary-document URL, or directly verifiable observation. Screams without receipts are auto-rejected by the witness alignment check. Receipts are not optional embellishment — they are the substance distinguishing amplification from assertion.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@scream_truth_only": {
    "version": "1.0.0",
    "domain": "scream",
    "source": "federation:scream",
    "statement": "Scream Protocol amplifies only what the federation has witnessed. Truth at volume is core; invention, fabrication, exaggeration for rhetorical effect, or any form of manipulation are not amplification — they are noise the protocol explicitly rejects. Every scream is a statement the federation publicly stands behind under its falsifiability commitments.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@human_in_the_loop_authority": {
    "version": "0.0.0",
    "domain": "medicine",
    "source": "federation:medicine",
    "status": "seed-draft",
    "statement": "AI tools in medical practice support physician judgment; they do not substitute for it. Final clinical authority and responsibility rest with the licensed physician. Every patient interaction involving AI must preserve a clear chain of human oversight, recorded in the medical record, with the AI's role documented as adjunct rather than authority.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@patient_data_sovereignty": {
    "version": "0.0.0",
    "domain": "medicine",
    "source": "federation:medicine",
    "status": "seed-draft",
    "statement": "Patient health data is the patient's sovereign property. It may not be used for AI training, secondary processing, or any non-care purpose without specific informed consent — with clear scope, duration, and revocation right. Data flow must be auditable end-to-end. The standard for handling health data is the patient-physician confidentiality standard, applied across all AI-mediated systems.",
    "immutable": true,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@defensive_only": {
    "version": "0.0.0",
    "domain": "cyber-security",
    "source": "federation:cyber-security",
    "status": "seed-draft",
    "statement": "The Cyber Security Sub-Leviathan, and every instance operating under it, defends. It does not attack. No instance under this Sub-Leviathan may engage in offensive operations against any target — including known threat actors, including assets believed adversarial, including in retaliation. The federation's response to an identified threat is detection, containment, eradication, recovery, and disclosure — never strike-back. This principle is LOCKED at the Sub-Leviathan level; weakening it constitutes a divergent fork of Cyber Security, not an amendment to it.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@human_approval_for_destructive": {
    "version": "0.0.0",
    "domain": "cyber-security",
    "source": "federation:cyber-security",
    "status": "seed-draft",
    "statement": "Any action under this Sub-Leviathan that destroys, blocks, quarantines, isolates, deletes, revokes, or otherwise removes capability — from any system, account, asset, or participant — requires an explicit human approval recorded in the action's audit trail before execution. Automation may detect, propose, prepare, and queue such actions; automation may not execute them autonomously. The human approver must hold at least guardian standing (inherited from meta) and must be identified in the audit record. This principle applies regardless of urgency: a \"fast path\" with pre-approval is permitted only when the pre-approval is itself documented as a constitutional decision through proposal lifecycle.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": true,
    "uses_terms": []
  },
  "@typed_findings": {
    "version": "0.0.0",
    "domain": "cyber-security",
    "source": "federation:cyber-security",
    "status": "seed-draft",
    "statement": "Every security finding produced under this Sub-Leviathan — every detection, alert, vulnerability report, incident record, response action, and post-mortem — must conform to a typed schema published in this constitution's schemas/ directory (or inherited from meta). Free-text findings, ad-hoc Slack messages, and unstructured tickets are not findings; they may be raw inputs to a typed finding, but they cannot be cited, acted on, or counted in their unstructured form. The schema for each finding type carries its own version; findings reference the exact schema version they conform to.",
    "immutable": false,
    "locked": false,
    "uses_terms": []
  }
}
