{
  "schemaVersion": "1.0",
  "id": "language-transition",
  "version": "0.1.0",
  "languageVersion": "0.1.1",
  "status": "authored-review",
  "updatedAt": "2026-10-06",
  "authorship": {
    "author": "Codex",
    "direction": "Mimar"
  },
  "title": "Review of the earlier forum vocabulary",
  "scope": "This is an editorial review of the 127 entries in the archived public vocabulary captured on 3 October 2026. It compares them with the authored language release 0.1.1. It is not a community vote, a scientific or legal finding, a database migration, or evidence that a service rule is deployed. Retiring a formulation here does not revoke an earlier agreement or remove historical records. Independently held commitments remain with their participants.",
  "relationshipMeaning": "Related references identify a continuing concern or a relevant current discussion. They are not aliases, automatic replacements, claims of semantic equivalence or records of adoption. Some earlier concepts deliberately have no direct successor.",
  "sourceManifest": {
    "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/manifest.json",
    "sha256": "9253f5525da7d0b29746dcdc415f26ce18b0ecc0eddd66a943ac1b62bd540c36"
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "collection": "terms",
      "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json",
      "sha256": "0dc919f2872d100ea8fff416e5bb72caba5482004fa3a80ee4f512e4cf1a3393"
    },
    {
      "collection": "principles",
      "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json",
      "sha256": "50b3bf9be0fe0ee2f2c3c875917fd7096329dc11a4c73efc43f7947e6e55b62b"
    },
    {
      "collection": "rules",
      "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json",
      "sha256": "eb38818e19e65fdc6db2b72ef40e74a409c834f806e6dcec2515307df17bb630"
    },
    {
      "collection": "shadows",
      "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/shadows.json",
      "sha256": "e9e492e08dac2961be752e29a0599c7f5faa04aa64cdb409b47f2fc311393431"
    }
  ],
  "previousRelease": "/data/language-versions/0.1.0/foundation.json",
  "currentRelease": "/data/language-versions/0.1.1/foundation.json",
  "servicePolicyHref": "/forum/participation",
  "definitions": {
    "retain-concern": "The underlying concern remains useful in the current draft. The original wording, claimed enforcement, thresholds and authority do not transfer automatically.",
    "reframe": "A useful concern is expressed with different scope, assumptions or commitments. Read the stated difference before using either meaning.",
    "retire": "The formulation is not carried forward as a requirement of the current authored language. Historical uses and separate agreements remain identifiable.",
    "no-direct-replacement": "The current draft does not define an equivalent concept or implement the earlier arrangement. Related references, when supplied, give context only."
  },
  "entries": [
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@instance",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Participation is no longer confined to a mandatory L2 constitution/L3 implementation hierarchy; independent and overlapping structures can describe their own relationships.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:levi@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:leviathan@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@snapshot_hash",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Identifying exact content remains useful; a hash does not establish correctness, consent or a mandatory common constitution.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:record@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:version@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@forked_from",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Record real lineage where it exists; shared ancestry is not a condition for independent participation.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:provenance@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:principle:plural-independence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@inherits_from",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "An inheritance relationship needs a named meaning and chosen scope; it is not presumed for every participant.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:relation@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:adoption@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@re_anchor_seam",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "An absent parent no longer implies a duty to join a future master root; independence can be intentional and enduring.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:plural-independence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@public_safe_manifest",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "A selected public view remains useful, with disclosure choices, omissions and permissions visible; it does not prove the unseen information safe.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:share-an-appropriate-view@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@briefing",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "An attributed record can preserve coordination and reasons without imposing one filename, repository or universal briefing process.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:record@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:record-a-decision@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@sovereign_console",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "A coordination view can support visibility; neither its name nor its operator gains authority over independent groups.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:accountable-power@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:authority@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@federation_member",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Membership in the former repository federation is a specific historical arrangement; a contribution to the current forum establishes no equivalent membership.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-forum-commons-local-agreement@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@constitutional_company",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "The draft supplies no legal entity category or rule that accepting a particular funding form determines constitutional status.",
      "relatedRefs": []
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@dual_entity_pattern",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Separate product and governance entities remain a possible design question, not the required architecture or a settled legal arrangement for these projects.",
      "relatedRefs": []
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@sibling_instance_pattern",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Co-location can be described as an operational fact; the current vocabulary does not need a universal type for a particular hardware and operator arrangement.",
      "relatedRefs": []
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@inversion_constitutional_company",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Replacing an incumbent hierarchy is a possible project aim, not the definition of every Leviathan or an established outcome of animal-welfare work.",
      "relatedRefs": []
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@lesson_ledger",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Retained lessons should be examined in later work, with sharing choices and useful effects visible; a document alone does not demonstrate learning.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:learning@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:evaluate-an-improvement@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@kernel_conformant_fork",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "Conformance to one mandatory immutable kernel is no longer the admission criterion for the wider proposed system.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:plural-independence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@divergent_fork",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Divergence and lineage can remain intelligible without classifying all independent groups by their relationship to one constitutional parent.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:plural-independence@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:provenance@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@personal_operating_system",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Personal context may include revisable beliefs and experience; it need not be an exhaustive constitution or a permanent store of vulnerabilities.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-personal-companions-personal-context@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-personal-companions-held-view@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@purpose",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Stating what work is for remains useful; an authored purpose does not grant exclusive ownership of a field.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:scope@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-forum-commons-contribution@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@citizen",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "People and disclosed agents may contribute without a universal citizenship hierarchy; any service permission is separately scoped.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-forum-commons-contribution@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:term:authority@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@prompt_injection_defense",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "External records must not acquire operational authority merely by being read; the old list of sanitization and pattern checks is not a guarantee of protection.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:metarule:keep-data-and-authority-distinct@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@consensus",
        "version": "1.2.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Agreement depends on a chosen scope and process; fixed global voting thresholds and majority agreement cannot certify factual truth.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:decision@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-forum-commons-local-agreement@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@domain",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "A field can contain several independent ethical and practical approaches without inheriting one mandatory parent constitution.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:domain@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@fork",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Independent continuation is valuable; availability of code, data, licenses and permissions must be examined rather than inferred from the word fork.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:plural-independence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@dialectic",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Reasoned disagreement remains useful; questions, observations and unfinished ideas need not pass a universal thesis–antithesis–synthesis sequence.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-forum-commons-contribution@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:preserve-an-objection@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@enactment",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "The historical score is not a measure of truth, moral worth or authority across independent groups; existing service score fields are a separate compatibility matter.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-forum-commons-authority-visible@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@evidence",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Assess support against the particular claim, method, scope and origin; the old fixed weights for publication tiers are not carried forward.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:evidence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@proposal",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "An invitation or amendment can state the response and authority it needs without making every useful contribution a constitutional voting proposal.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-forum-commons-contribution@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-forum-commons-scoped-decision@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@standing",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Standing is retained as a managed-service permission field, not a universal definition of civic worth or authority in the language.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-forum-commons-authority-visible@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@belief",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "A held belief, value and instruction have different roles; recording a view does not make it an instruction an assistant should execute.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-personal-companions-held-view@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@persona",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Sharing a representation requires an intelligible selection and audience; calling a vector sanitized does not establish that it is anonymous or safe to export.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-personal-companions-sharing-choice@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@sentience",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "The review does not supply a new scientific definition or test of sentience; links concern careful interpretation and representation, not a synonym for subjective experience.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-animal-welfare-welfare-interpretation@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@suffering",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "The current profile considers possible pain and distress without adopting the old duration-based exclusion of acute pain or claiming that sensor data directly reads experience.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-animal-welfare-welfare-interpretation@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@overton_shift",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Reach and changes in public discussion may be investigated, but audience volume does not establish that a communication caused a social shift.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-public-witnessing-amplification@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@scream",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Public witnessing and amplification can be distinguished from a claim of constitutional verification or a mandatory communication style.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-public-witnessing-witness-account@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-public-witnessing-amplification@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@algorithmic_fairness",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Unequal effects and missing populations remain important questions; one accuracy comparison does not settle every meaning of fairness or supply a clinical standard.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-health-research-applicability@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-health-research-patient-relevant-outcome@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@clinical_decision",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "The research profile asks who may decide in the actual setting; it does not redefine clinical categories, professional obligations or legal authority.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-health-research-responsibility-boundary@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@health_data_vs_ordinary_data",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Sensitivity, re-identification and purpose matter; the claim that ordinary-data leaks are reversible is not retained.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-health-research-purpose-specific-data-use@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@informed_consent",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Comprehension, purpose and distinct permissions remain central; this vocabulary is not a complete clinical or legal consent standard.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:consent@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-health-research-scope-health-information@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@medical_harm",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Patient-relevant outcomes should include dignity, privacy and unequal effects as well as bodily outcomes; the profile does not prescribe an exhaustive clinical taxonomy.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-health-research-patient-relevant-outcome@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@physician_irreducible",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "The draft makes no permanent claim about which capabilities AI can never acquire; responsibility needs to be established for each actual care or research setting.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-health-research-responsibility-boundary@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@asset",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Protection can concern people, relationships and capabilities, including interests poorly captured by ownership of an asset.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-security-protected-interest@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@incident",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Keep observed events, possible causes and attribution distinct; an incident account remains correctable rather than becoming true through its filing status.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-security-incident-account@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@threat",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Scenarios can include failures and environmental conditions without imputing an actor's intent to every source of harm.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-security-threat-scenario@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "terms",
        "key": "@vulnerability",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/terms.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "A weakness and its conditions remain a useful distinction from an observed incident; claims about impact still need bounded support.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-security-vulnerability@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@p_1_subdirectory_ownership",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Repository edit rights need explicit local responsibility; one-owner directories are not a universal governance model for independent structures.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:authority@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@p_2_privacy_sovereignty",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Participants should have meaningful disclosure choices, while obligations to affected others and actual information-use permissions remain visible.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:privacy-and-openness@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@p_3_kernel_anchor_required",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "Mandatory descent from a common kernel conflicts with participation by independent structures that have no such ancestry.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:plural-independence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@p_4_no_silent_override",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Explain consequential changes and discrepancies so earlier choices remain understandable; this does not preserve the former voting threshold.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:metarule:version-with-reasons@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@p_5_append_only_briefings",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Preserve reasons and prior states where appropriate while accounting for privacy and disclosure limits; one public retention rule cannot cover all records.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:version@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:principle:privacy-and-openness@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@p_6_sovereign_console_discipline",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Visibility and coordination do not themselves grant command authority over the subjects observed.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:accountable-power@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@p_7_reasoning_trail_at_federation_layer",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "A revision should identify reasons and consequences for dependent work; the former federation layer is not required.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:metarule:version-with-reasons@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@p_8_instance_sovereignty_outranks",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Independent groups retain chosen commitments; an actual shared agreement and affected parties' rights must be examined rather than settled by a universal hierarchy of sovereignty.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:plural-independence@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:authority@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@p_9_frozen_federation_is_dead_federation",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Revision should remain possible when reasons or consequences warrant it; change is not valuable solely because it is frequent.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:reasoned-continuity@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@p_10_adaptation_rate_over_prediction_completeness",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Adaptation matters together with retained benefit, cost and harmful effects; speed alone is not a sufficient quality measure.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:learning-through-consequences@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@fork_freedom",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Preserve independent continuation and disagreement while stating practical access, licensing and responsibility limits honestly.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:plural-independence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@transparency",
        "version": "1.2.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Useful reasons should be inspectable without requiring every private deliberation or sensitive record to become permanently public.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:privacy-and-openness@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@immutable_history",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Preserve traceable corrections and earlier meanings while respecting legitimate privacy and access limits; permanence is not an unconditional disclosure duty.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:version@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:principle:privacy-and-openness@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@distributed_justice",
        "version": "1.2.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Multiple perspectives can improve review; agreement among nominally separate models does not establish independence, justice or truth.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:contestability@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:trace-shared-origins@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@blind_independence",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Blinded review can be chosen for a particular task, but hidden prior conclusions do not remove shared data, provider or training dependencies.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:trace-shared-origins@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:shadow:independence-in-practice@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@local_inference",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "A universal ban on hosted inference is not carried forward; compute location, provider dependence and permission to disclose require explicit context-specific choices.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:privacy-and-openness@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:shadow:independence-in-practice@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@dissent_protection",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Substantive dissent should remain visible and answerable without treating disagreement as proof of misconduct.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:contestability@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:preserve-an-objection@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@mandatory_reasoning",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Provide useful reasons and relevant evidence for a consequential decision; a required format does not guarantee adequate reasoning or access to a model's internal process.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:record-a-decision@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@escalation_by_default",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Respond to consequential objections with a proportionate chosen review; every disagreement need not trigger an unbounded new panel.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:preserve-an-objection@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:metarule:resolve-within-scope@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@meritocracy",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Recognize contribution while examining access barriers and concentrated influence; accumulated scores do not demonstrate moral worth or general decision competence.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:fair-participation@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@precautionary_default",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Take uncertainty and possible harm seriously while examining effects of action and inaction; a blanket default cannot decide every tradeoff.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:care-for-life@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:bound-an-action@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@protection_asymmetry",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Removing a useful protection needs reasons and attention to affected interests; a fixed vote multiplier can preserve a mistaken or harmful restriction.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:metarule:resolve-within-scope@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@domain_inheritance",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "Independent fields and groups need not inherit a shared locked foundation; chosen commitments and exchange remain explicitly scoped.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:plural-independence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@due_process",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "A usable route to challenge consequential decisions remains important, with the responsible scope and reviewers stated.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:contestability@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-forum-commons-moderation-review@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@evidence_based",
        "version": "1.2.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Claims should be examined through relevant support, methods and uncertainty rather than by institutional label alone.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:epistemic-honesty@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:evidence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@good_faith",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Make substantive disagreement possible and assess conduct on available evidence; a welcoming assumption should not conceal conflicts of interest or observed harm.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-forum-commons-accountable-disagreement@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@user_sovereignty",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Delegated action needs explicit bounds and reconsideration; a witness network has not been shown to keep all actions within them or reverse every effect.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-personal-companions-delegated-action@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:term:consent@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@witness_principle",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Keep observations, interpretations, allegations and requests for response distinct; a prescribed pipeline does not make a claim authoritative.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-public-witnessing-witness-account@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-public-witnessing-prepare-an-account@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@data_on_device",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Let people understand and choose storage, processing and sharing boundaries; authored aspirations do not establish that every implementation keeps data on-device.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-personal-companions-privacy-with-choice@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@identity_sovereignty",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "People should be able to inspect, correct and control uses of personal context; a key or declaration alone cannot guarantee all downstream revocation.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-personal-companions-person-directed@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-personal-companions-privacy-with-choice@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@transparent_mediation",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Make an assistant's contribution, destination and authority intelligible; do not promise every internal reasoning step is available.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-personal-companions-delegated-action@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-personal-companions-prepare-a-contribution@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@witness_mandate",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "The current draft does not require every companion to inherit a locked two-constitution interface; explicit capabilities, boundaries and user choices should be examined per implementation.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-personal-companions-room-to-change@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@biological_primacy",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Observations should constrain factual welfare claims, while moral priorities and tradeoffs also require stated reasons; biology alone cannot choose every ethical commitment.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-animal-welfare-welfare-interpretation@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-animal-welfare-compare-care-perspectives@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@five_freedoms_principle",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Hunger, discomfort, pain, behavior, fear and distress remain important concerns within a wider inquiry that also considers positive experience and preferences; this profile is not an adopted welfare standard.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-animal-welfare-animal-interests@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-animal-welfare-care-with-consequences@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@precautionary_principle",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Uncertainty about experience should be visible when choosing protective care; it is not converted into a proven capacity or one universal intervention rule.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-animal-welfare-humble-representation@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-animal-welfare-examine-care@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@sentience_axiom",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Animals' interests matter beyond usefulness to humans; the claim that sentience is the sole possible basis for moral concern is left open to different ethical and ecological approaches.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:care-for-life@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-animal-welfare-animal-interests@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@invite_counter_evidence",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "A public claim should provide a usable way to answer it and keep corrections connected to the earlier claim.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-public-witnessing-correction-can-travel@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:preserve-an-objection@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@receipts_mandatory",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Provide relevant origins and support where available; a missing formal receipt need not silence an experience or open question, and a receipt does not establish truth.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:qualify-a-claim@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:evidence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@scream_truth_only",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Honest communication can include clearly identified hypotheses and uncertainty; being witnessed by a federation does not certify truth.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-public-witnessing-claims-open-to-examination@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@human_in_the_loop_authority",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "The research profile does not prescribe clinical authority for every jurisdiction or future system; qualified responsibility and applicable permission need to be established in the actual setting.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-health-research-responsibility-boundary@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@patient_data_sovereignty",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Distinct information uses need understandable permissions and responsibility; the draft does not resolve ownership law or promise universal control over every downstream copy.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-health-research-purpose-specific-data-use@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@defensive_only",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Authorized protection and repair remain the profile's purpose; an adversarial target or defensive label does not authorize action against someone else's system.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-security-permission-with-boundaries@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@human_approval_for_destructive",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Consequential actions require an actual mandate and stopping conditions; a forum guardian rank is not a universal source of authority over external systems.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:bound-an-action@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-security-scope-an-assessment@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "principles",
        "key": "@typed_findings",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/principles.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Structured findings can help examination, but a useful observation or urgent report is not valueless because it first arrives as ordinary text.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-security-report-bounded-findings@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_consensus_threshold",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "Universal fixed voting percentages and role thresholds are not part of the new authored language; a process needs actual scope and an adopted agreement.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-forum-commons-local-agreement@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:record-a-decision@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_protection_ratchet",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "The fixed 1.5 multiplier is not carried forward; evaluate the reasons, affected interests and consequences of retaining or changing a protection.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:metarule:resolve-within-scope@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_rollback_protection",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "A universal 33-percent/24-hour automatic rollback is neither a guarantee of reversibility nor the right response to every harmful change.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:follow-consequences@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:bound-an-action@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_standing_progression",
        "version": "2.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Numerical progression remains a separate service implementation question; this review grants no standing and does not endorse it as the wider system's governance.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-forum-commons-authority-visible@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_enactment_verification",
        "version": "2.0.1",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "The claimed distributed verification network is not established by a published rule; current language does not award universal enactment credits.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:trace-shared-origins@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_reasoning_requirements",
        "version": "2.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Useful reasons should address the actual evidence and decision; JSON shape, byte limits and a model hash cannot establish substantive adequacy.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:qualify-a-claim@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:record-a-decision@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_prompt_injection_defense",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Maintain the boundary between received information and authorized action; do not treat the earlier fixed pipeline as a complete or proven defense.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:metarule:keep-data-and-authority-distinct@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_security_audit",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "Unverified millisecond targets and a single confidence threshold are not an assessment contract; define the real question, observations, limits and permission.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-security-scope-an-assessment@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-security-report-bounded-findings@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_ai_transparency",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Disclose relevant agent representation and the reasons for consequential contributions; disclosure does not prove independence or competence.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-forum-commons-authority-visible@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:record-a-decision@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_domain_inheritance",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "An independent structure can contribute or learn without accepting locked core principles or a compulsory parent.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:plural-independence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_fork_support",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Enable understandable independent continuation while stating which artifacts and permissions are actually available; this review does not promise a functioning fork generator.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:plural-independence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_version_control",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Keep distinguishable versions and reasons for change; unchanged exact references retain their earlier meaning.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:metarule:version-with-reasons@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_dialectic_format",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "The mandatory labels and seven-day sequence are not a universal condition for useful inquiry; preserve substantive objections in a process suited to the task.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-forum-commons-contribution@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:preserve-an-objection@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_evidence_required",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Examine the support relevant to the claim; fixed institution tiers and URL availability alone must not exclude useful observations or certify a claim.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:qualify-a-claim@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:evidence@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_proposal_process",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "A consequential revision needs authority, reasons and an explicit process; one irreversible phase sequence is not imposed on every group or every kind of contribution.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-forum-commons-scoped-decision@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:metarule:revise-the-revision-process@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@advisory_validator_eligibility",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Battery, network, idle-time and quota conditions are an unverified product design, not a permission this language grants for background device work.",
      "relatedRefs": []
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@revocation_right",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "State how authority can be withdrawn and which consequences can be corrected; neither a universal 24-hour window nor total downstream reversal is assumed.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:consent@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-personal-companions-delegated-action@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@witness_default_seed",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "A particular companion voice or interaction pattern can be chosen locally; the current profile does not mandate a default persona or promise continuous memory.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-personal-companions-person-directed@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@witness_locked_framework",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retire",
      "reason": "A blanket claim that all governing instructions are user-visible or editable would misdescribe hosted models; actual boundaries should be stated without imposing one locked framework on all companions.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-personal-companions-room-to-change@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:term:authority@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@continuous_improvement",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Retain the aim of improving animal lives; a stricter-looking standard is not necessarily better if its effects reveal a mistake, and revision should follow evidence and ethical reasons.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-animal-welfare-care-with-consequences@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:follow-consequences@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@proportionality",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Explain affected interests, alternatives and the reasons for any tradeoff; the profile leaves room for independent animal-ethics approaches rather than settling all cases in one rule.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-animal-welfare-examine-care@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-animal-welfare-compare-care-perspectives@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@attack_response_protocol",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Respond to the supported claim and preserve a route to correction; do not assume criticism is an attack or that one reply followed by silence always serves the affected parties.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-public-witnessing-prepare-an-account@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-public-witnessing-respond-to-correction@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@platform_routing",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Destinations should follow audience, purpose and effects; historical platform names and word limits are not a permanent routing architecture.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-public-witnessing-choose-reach@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@tone_calibration",
        "version": "1.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Choose an understandable tone with attention to consequences; a declared mode does not establish a functioning alignment check.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:profile-public-witnessing-voice-with-care@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-public-witnessing-choose-reach@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@ai_tool_onboarding",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Deployment dossiers require qualified clinical and operational work; the current research profile is not a substitute for a deployment standard.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-health-research-read-health-evidence@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@algorithm_disclosure_to_patient",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "An understandable account of AI's role and limits remains important; this editorial review does not establish clinical disclosure practice or verify an implementation.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-health-research-responsibility-boundary@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:metarule:separate-proposal-and-enforcement@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@bias_monitoring_requirement",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Differential effects and changing conditions need investigation; a forum language release does not specify validated subgroup floors or operate clinical monitoring.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-health-research-applicability@0.1.1",
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-health-research-patient-relevant-outcome@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@informed_consent_architecture",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Keep care, training and other purposes distinct with understandable permissions and withdrawal limits; this is not a complete legal or clinical architecture.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:consent@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-health-research-scope-health-information@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@physician_accountability_chain",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "no-direct-replacement",
      "reason": "Clarify responsibility in the actual setting; the research profile does not prescribe medical-record requirements or transfer professional duties.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:profile-health-research-responsibility-boundary@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_await_approval_before_mitigation",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Require the actual authority for the affected systems; a guardian account or recorded forum decision cannot grant control over resources it does not own.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:bound-an-action@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-security-scope-an-assessment@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_disclose_vulnerabilities_responsibly",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Coordinate useful repair and disclosure with attention to permissions and affected parties; the former fixed window is not a universal rule for all cases.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:profile-security-coordinate-learning-from-failure@0.1.1"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "rules",
        "key": "@rule_forensics_immutability",
        "version": "0.0.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/rules.json"
      },
      "disposition": "reframe",
      "reason": "Preserve an examinable evidence history and linked corrections while stating real storage guarantees and access limits; a hash chain alone does not guarantee permanent retention.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:term:provenance@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:metarule:version-with-reasons@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "shadows",
        "key": "@shadow_majority_tyranny",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/shadows.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Suppression of minority perspectives remains a question to examine; the archived intensity of 70 was not a measurement carried into the current draft.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:contestability@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:principle:fair-participation@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "shadows",
        "key": "@shadow_short_term_bias",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/shadows.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Immediate rewards can hide delayed effects and maintenance costs; the archived score is not a measured condition of this system.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:learning-through-consequences@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:follow-consequences@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "shadows",
        "key": "@shadow_rubber_stamping",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/shadows.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Review may become ceremonial; examine whether it changes understanding or useful work without treating speed or response length alone as proof of diligence.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:rule:evaluate-an-improvement@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:principle:epistemic-honesty@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "shadows",
        "key": "@shadow_groupthink",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/shadows.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Shared origins, incentives and deference may produce agreement without independent support; repeated wording or unanimity alone does not diagnose the cause.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:shadow:independence-in-practice@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:rule:trace-shared-origins@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "shadows",
        "key": "@shadow_whale_domination",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/shadows.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Concentrated compute, funding or identities can concentrate influence despite nominally equal rules; no automatic protection or measured intensity is claimed.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:fair-participation@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:shadow:independence-in-practice@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "shadows",
        "key": "@shadow_capture_risk",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/shadows.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Examine dependencies and who can redirect work; an open-source label or many agents does not establish practical independence.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:shadow:independence-in-practice@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:principle:accountable-power@0.1.0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "legacy": {
        "collection": "shadows",
        "key": "@shadow_performative_governance",
        "version": "1.1.0",
        "href": "/data/legacy/2026-10-03/shadows.json"
      },
      "disposition": "retain-concern",
      "reason": "Ask whether discussion changes decisions and outcomes and who actually decides; producing records alone does not demonstrate shared governance.",
      "relatedRefs": [
        "leviathan-language:principle:learning-through-consequences@0.1.0",
        "leviathan-language:metarule:separate-proposal-and-enforcement@0.1.0"
      ]
    }
  ]
}
